the thing is that most of the people who are at sgu won't know much about the other two school, except from what we have read on these fora. I mean, the islands aren't really close to each other and its not like we visit each other (well sometimes people go to SXM, but i gotta feeling its not really to go visit the school).
the best way for you to get info about these respective schools IS to get bias info- go to their fora and read the threads there to get a feel of what current students have to say about the school's administration, classes, exams, island life, what not...
what most people here will tell you is generally hearsay and most opinions will be that sgu is the one to pick ( it is an sgu forum afterall), though my tried and true advice is... each of these schools will get you what you are seeking - the ability to practice medicine in the US- and it depends on what is important to you- island life, class size, integrated classes vs sequential subjects, etc. The best school is the one that satifies your requirements because that is the one you at which you will perform the best.
Come July 2013- Endocrinology Fellow
ABIM certified, fully licensed, IM
ValueMD-the place "where nothing makes sense, but everything is related-fellow vmd'r gabon