PDA

View Full Version : NOT THE WORST;......DEFINETLY NOT THE BEST BY ANY MEANS


former student
06-02-2003, 10:16 AM
Dear Prospective Students,

You will read lot's of information on this forum regarding pro's and con's about attending Spartan. Spartan is not the worst school you can go to because on a very basic level, you will get what you need such as didactics in basic science, clinical rotations in the states and in mexico, or where else you set them up, certification for private loans and to take the usmle, and most of all a medical school diploma. So...in a "nut shell" you basically get what you need. Now if you are a enterprising student that can manage independently, by setting up your own roataions, good self study for the boards without depending on proper didactic instruction from the school, and not too terribly dependant on student loans..this school could work out for you.

On the other hand, students who need more supervised and traditional guidance may not do as well. The classes taught on the campus are the right courses for basic science and the school use the right books, but the problem is.. most instructors are not really qualified to teach the course, or savvy enough to stream line the course so the student can get the "meat and potatoes" of what's really going on so they can apply the information to high yield learning for board passage. A large percentage of students leave the island not ready/qualified to take the usmle. More money is spent on review courses.

ROTATIONS:
I do like the fact that Spartan will let you set up your own rotations. So if you know people this could be an asset. What if you don't have any connections or the skill to find them on your own? Then your basically at the mercy of the school. They will try to convince you to go to mexico for rotations because you can study for the boards, the cost is cheap and you get more hands on there than in the U.S. Which is partially true...
.
The down side to this plan is 1. The hospital in mexico is inadequate training for junior and senior medical students who are planning to return to the U.S. for practice. The clerkships are really observerships with minimal to no hands on training. There is a language barrier for most students, there is no training of patient interview (b/c of language barrier), clinical skill assessment, or physical exams. So if a student did all of there training in mexico, he or she would not have the necessary skills for residency, which is a disadvantage, so about this being more hands on ..you will have to decide. :(

Clinicals in the U.S.: Spartan is not formally affiliated with any hospital, but they do work with a few tuition based clinical sites. These students are paying a additional $300-$350/wk., which is absurd., most student that I have spoken to said the training was o.k., some rotations are better than others. For these rates your better off setting them up yourself.

FINANCIAL AID:
Spartan does not have stafford loans..and I doubt it that they will be getting them anytime soon. Spartan has been telling students since 1997 that the loans are just around the corner and they are working on it. This is 2003...you decide, but I wouldn't hold my breathe waiting on these loans.

Terri loans have been around for a while and most students are getting these if they can pass the credit check. If you credit is not up to par, the school has no other plans for you or no advice on what you can do.

Med Achiever loans are new, but from what I understand they are credit based loans as well.

Something to think about as well...students that do receive loans are complaining about not getting enough loan money especially when they are paying heavy fee's for rotations. For some reason the school only wants to pay for the cost of education (minimally) and not give students enough money to live on. They are a lot of SHSU students who receive loans and are totally broke.....you figure that one out. So you married one's with kids..this is something to think about.

ADMINISTRATION/STUDENT ASSISTANCE
Most student are not satisfied with the service they receive. The staff is not professional or knowledgable as most med schools about medical school affairs.

So yes...Spartan is cheap..but you are going to get what you pay for. If you can deal with what I shared with you...then come on down...we would love to have.


FORMER STUDENT

Beaker
06-02-2003, 11:12 AM
former student, i agree with some of what u say but not everything. and i also wonder about your motves since your screen name indicates that you are no longer a student :?: but overall i appreciate the balanced information which u provided.

Clinicals in the U.S.: Spartan is not formally affiliated with any hospital, but they do work with a few tuition based clinical sites. These students are paying a additional $300-$350/wk., which is absurd., most student that I have spoken to said the training was o.k., some rotations are better than others. For these rates your better off setting them up yourself.


$300-$350 is absurd b/c it doesn't really cost that much. some sites that charge extra money might cost between $100-$250 per week on top of tuition (depending on the site). i've never heard of $300-350?? but for the sake of arguement, even if it was that high in a particular highly desired site that cost that much plus tuition, it would still be less money than the tuition that other students in the same hospital rotations from other schools are paying :? the difference is that in other schools you are stuck paying the high tuition regardless of which site you go to (which you cant choose in other schools). at spartan you can decide how much extra u will pay by deciding which site u want. "So yes...Spartan is cheap..but you are going to get what you pay for." this is also true for clinical sites. the better ones might run u a little more. but once again its still less than other schools tuition for the same sites.

spartan will give u the opportunity to practice medicine in the usa. no one ever said that spartan was the best school. but i have heard people say that its the best for the money :wink:

peace

currentstudent
06-02-2003, 12:54 PM
the teachers really do help you out......u learn alot here.......they set up health fairs for us to attend......and Stafford loans will be in shortly!......they only send the students who hardly pass the basic sciences to mexico.....otherwise you are able to pick and choose your clinicals in the USA......the school has a FORMAL affliation with a few very good hospitals as well.....i guess the school has just changed since you were here last!

former student
06-02-2003, 02:26 PM
Dear Beaker,

No negative motive at all...no bad feelings toward the school...I'm a graduate and a resident and proud of my Spartan affiliations...but there is information about our school that is constantly over looked that should be shared, so that students and potential students can make appropriate decisions. :D

former student
06-02-2003, 02:42 PM
Dear Futurestudent,

I'm sure the teachers do help you out, but the question is, Are you getting the help you need to become a competent intern physician?

Keep in mind...most of the professors have not or do not practice medicine or do they hold a St. Lucien medical license, maybe with the exception of one or two whom are actual St. Lucien nationals.

Yes you can pick and choose clinicals in the USA (exception CA,TX,IL), but you will be setting them up yourself. As far as formal affiliations, ask the hospital and see what they say...I could be wrong but I doubt it.

The only thing that has changed since I've graduated, is that less students are transferring from Ross to Spartan, more Spartan students are transfering out to other schools such as St. Christopher, and the campus is expanding.

The reason I am responding to your note...not b/c I want to rag on the school, but to let you know, don't be blind sided by misinformation. The more you know about your school the better you can take care of yourself and be succeessful.

FORMER STUDENT

MDwannabe
06-03-2003, 10:52 AM
I am another future student . Can you or anybody tell me if I can do my clinical in NY & still be eligible to do my residency there too. I have read in this forum about a certain new law that would make u ineligible for residency in New York if u did your clinical rotation in that state

ms4sgu
06-03-2003, 11:23 AM
Unless your school has NY approval (spartan doesnt) you can do a max of 12 weeks of rotations in NY state.

Beaker
06-03-2003, 02:53 PM
former student, sorry i misunderstood your username to mean that u withdrew from school. i guess congrats are in order on your graduation and residency :D

i must however respectfully disagree on another one of your statements.
Yes you can pick and choose clinicals in the USA (exception CA,TX,IL), but you will be setting them up yourself.
i'm not sure about tx (although I've read unconfirmed reports on this forum that TX does have spartan residents), but i'm not gonna pretend like i do and give false information about it either. but IL is definitely a state where spartan clinicals are done. there are a few affiliated hospitals around the chicago area where spartan will set your rotations up for you. i happen to know this from personal experience, but i wonder where your information came from?? an even bigger point is that if your wrong about that point what makes you think that your right about the others?

i dont mind that some people point out both the pros and cons of whatever school coz they all have both. but it really upsets me when people give false information. i've seen too many posts trying to say that spartan students cant go here or there when i personally know of people in those place right now. another big misconception is that spartan doesnt set up your rotations for you. this is simply not true. just like in other schools spartan will setup your schedule and send you different places at the schools convenience. the better spots are reserved for the better qualified students (also like other schools). but spartan students have become spoiled thinking that they would rather set up thier own schedules as they want and where they want (most other schools dont let you do this). this doesnt meant that spartan wont do it for you. it usually means that the student didnt get great grades or wants to start before passing step 1 or wants to go to a specific place at a specific time.

dont take this the wrong way former student. this is not directed only at u. its more about all the ppl around here that post hearsay like its a fact when its really just spreading rumors whether they mean to or not. like i already said i agree with some of the things u say, other things i dont know enough about to dispute them, while others i just know for a fact to be false. so please continue to provide both pros and cons about spartan, but please try harder to use your own experiences or verified sources of info. best of luck with your residency.

peace

former student
06-03-2003, 07:28 PM
Dear Beaker,

Excellent point....I did make a mistake, I meant Indiana, not Illinois, I got my abbreviations wrong. You are right about Chicago, I have/had friends there as med students and now residents. Great city...no offense taken regarding the correction, as of matter of fact, I welcome it. The information I will share for the next week or two (I'm on vacation) is from what I know first hand. The thing is I want all of you to become better informed so your path to medicine will be a little easier for you than it was for us. It's not easy for alot of Spartan graduates to make it to residency, fact being, there not groomed for it. There are lot's of Spartan graduates who have diplomas hanging on their walls at home and that's it. I know a few of them, but there is also a minority practicing and doing well. Those are the one's that kept themselves informed on the "real deal". I'll be around for a couple weeks. I would be more than happy to answer a few questions on the "real deal". I will say this. If you put all of your faith in the New Mexico office, without checking on them regularly to make sure they are taking care of your business, you could be possibly be left out in the cold. I don't dislike the office personnel..actually I had a great relationship with them. I just call it for what it is, and they are infamous for indirectly screwing over SHSU students. Spartan doesn't have major problems like other caribbean school, there problem is, they do not take care of the details and they are not student friendly. Whenever they master that task SHSU will be a great school.

KEEP THE QUESTIONS COMING

FORMER STUDENT

former student
06-03-2003, 07:36 PM
Dear MDwannabe,

You could extend your NY stay beyond 12 weeks, if you could somehow get rotations at a federal facility (e.g V.A., NHSC, BOP). The federal system supercedes the state system. Your biggest problem maybe, the big schools are all affiliated with the major teaching V.A. Give it a shot, you may just get in.


FORMER STUDENT

Kirst
06-11-2003, 02:59 AM
I heard something about how if you rotate in states like NY that your school does not have a full approval from, you will disqualify for licensure. Is this true? I don't know why the boards make things so complicated... You can rotate upto 12 weeks, you can't do residency unless through a VA program, but you can get licensed if you did a ACGME accredited residency training elsewhere in US. Or you can't rotate, but you can do residency, but you won't get a license after, etc etc!! :evil:

former student
06-11-2003, 02:07 PM
Dear Kirst,

Don't worry about New York, it won't be a problem. Spartan graduates are being matched there every year. Just do the 12 weeks of rotations and you will be fine. As I said in another post, to do more you would have to go federal system (this does not add to your previous 12 weeks), V.A,
National Health Service Corps, I.H.S., BOP, U.S. Postal Health Service, to name a few organizations.

First of all, get into medical school, that should keep you busy for a while.


FORMER STUDENT